SHORTLIST
Cover of Presumed Guilty

Presumed Guilty

Presumed Guilty by Scott Turow is one of 2026's most credible books, appearing on 1 of the year's most respected lists, including McKinsey & Company, for a Consensus Score of 15 out of 100.

Appears on these lists

Our take

AI-drafted

Turow brings Rusty Sabich back at 77, retired to Wisconsin's fictional Skageon region, and pulls him into defending his partner Bea's adopted son Aaron after Aaron's girlfriend is found dead following their joint disappearance. The racial dynamics — Aaron is Black, the rural county's justice system is not neutral — give the plot more explicit social weight than the earlier Kindle County books, and reviewers singled out Turow's courtroom choreography as still the novel's strongest instrument, the procedural machinery he's spent four decades perfecting. More measured notices pointed to the book's length: at over 500 pages, the case-building and interiority slow the momentum, so it reads more as a methodical character study of Rusty's late-life reckoning than as the taut suspense engine of the original Presumed Innocent.

In the press

How the Consensus Score is calculated

Our Consensus Score is our own transparent editorial metric — not a user rating. It weighs each list by the credibility of its source, how recent the listing is, and any award status. Here is the full breakdown.

SourceAuthorityRecencyAwardContribution
McKinsey & Company0.800.851.00×0.68
Weighted sum → Score0.6815

Similar consensus books

Because they appear on some of the same lists.

Abundance

Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson

Orbital

Samantha Harvey

Frequently asked

What lists is Presumed Guilty on?

Presumed Guilty appears on 1 list in our 2026 corpus, including McKinsey & Company.

What is its Consensus Score?

Presumed Guilty has a Consensus Score of 15 out of 100, our transparent editorial measure of how many credible lists agree on it.